Independence Day 2017: the year the border opened
Visa-free travel to the Schengen area began in June. Twenty-six years after independence, the most tangible change in ordinary life came not from an economic reform but from a queue that disappeared.
The twenty-sixth anniversary comes ten weeks after the single most popular thing that has happened in this country in a decade. On 11 June, visa-free short-stay travel to the Schengen area began for holders of Ukrainian biometric passports. Several hundred thousand people have used it already.
It is easy to file this under symbolism. It should not be. The economic effects are specific, measurable and mostly beginning rather than complete.
What visa-free actually changes
For business travel it removes a cost that was rarely counted: the two to three weeks and several hundred euros required to arrange a Schengen visa for a sales trip, a trade fair, a factory audit or a client meeting. Small Ukrainian exporters — the ones without a Warsaw office or a European distributor — could not respond to an inquiry from Germany within a month. Now they can respond within a week.
For services trade the effect is larger. Ukrainian software companies can send engineers to a client site without planning a quarter ahead. Design, engineering, marketing and consulting firms can pitch in person. This matters most for exactly the sectors that grow fastest and employ the best-paid workers.
For tourism the flow runs both ways, but the outbound side dominates so far. Low-cost carriers have added routes from Kyiv, Lviv and Odesa at a pace that airport capacity is struggling to match.
The part that is not comfortable
Visa-free travel does not confer the right to work, but it lowers the cost of exploring the option, and Ukraine's labour outflow has accelerated sharply. Poland alone has issued well over a million work-related documents to Ukrainians in the past two years. The Czech Republic, Hungary and the Baltic states are recruiting actively.
The wage differential is the whole explanation: a construction worker, a driver, a welder or a nurse earns three to five times more in Poland than in Ukraine, in a language that takes weeks rather than years to function in. No amount of patriotic messaging competes with that arithmetic.
The consequences are already visible in the domestic labour market. Wage inflation in construction, logistics and industry is running well ahead of productivity. Employers in western Ukraine report vacancies that stay open for months. For any business planning a Ukrainian operation, the assumption that labour is abundant and cheap is now approximately five years out of date in the west of the country and two years out of date everywhere else.
The rest of the year
Growth is around two and a half per cent — steady, unspectacular, and constrained by the loss of the eastern industrial base and by the trade blockade with the non-controlled territories imposed in the spring.
Pension reform is passing parliament this autumn, raising the effective retirement age through service-length requirements rather than a headline age increase. This is the politically clever way to do an unpopular thing, and it is overdue: pension spending has been among the highest in the world relative to GDP for a decade.
The Association Agreement enters into full force on 1 September, all chapters ratified. Practically this changes less than the DCFTA did in 2016, but it completes the legal framework and starts the clock on the political and sectoral cooperation provisions.
What to do about it
Two concrete recommendations. First, if your Ukrainian operation depends on wage arbitrage, rebuild the model around productivity now rather than after the third round of pay increases. The companies doing well here are the ones that invested in automation and training in 2015 and 2016.
Second, use the mobility. The single cheapest competitive advantage available to a Ukrainian exporter this year is showing up in person at European trade fairs, which was logistically impractical eighteen months ago and is now a train ticket.
Twenty-six years in
The anniversary lesson is about which reforms people feel. Banking supervision, procurement transparency and energy pricing were more important economically than visa liberalisation, and none of them changed how a single Ukrainian family experiences the world.
Reform programmes that deliver only invisible improvements lose elections and get reversed. This is not an argument against the difficult reforms — it is an argument for sequencing at least one visible win alongside them, which is the thing Ukraine finally managed this year.
Related in this archive
Share this analysis
Comments