What was built, what was left to decay, and what held
What was built, what was allowed to decay, and what the last four years demonstrated about which of the two mattered.
Looking back across two decades, Ukrainian infrastructure divides fairly cleanly into things that received investment and things that were kept running on maintenance until they could not be.
What was built
Airports and stadiums for the football tournament, which also produced the terminal capacity that later served evacuation and humanitarian traffic.
Private grain terminals at the ports, which are the reason the export trade reached the scale it did.
Roads, in a concentrated programme with better specifications and warranty terms.
And the digital layer: electronic procurement, electronic services, electronic customs transit — cheap to build relative to concrete and disproportionately useful.
What decayed
District heating networks, where pipe losses were known and unaddressed for decades. Water and wastewater treatment. Bridges reaching the end of their design life together. And the electricity distribution networks, maintained rather than renewed.
What the last four years showed
That redundancy and repairability matter more than modernity. The railway, an old and unglamorous system with many routes and its own repair workshops, performed better than newer, more centralised systems.
And that the digital layer was the cheapest resilience ever purchased: services that could be delivered on a phone continued when offices could not open.
The lesson for the next twenty
Build for repair and for multiple routes, not only for peak efficiency. The efficient system and the survivable system are not the same system, and the last four years priced the difference.
What separated what was built from what was left to decay over twenty years was usually whose budget the maintenance sat in. The rule I have seen on the ground is that infrastructure with a clear owner survives and infrastructure that belongs to everyone rots. The last four years tested that brutally, and what held was not the newest work but the most regularly maintained.
Share this analysis
Comments